The Issue Of Market Commodification - 1367 Words

There is an ongoing argument in philosophy to whether or not the market should be constrained to certain goods and services, as well as how much power governments should have when intervening in a regulated market. Most people believe that certain goods and services should be kept out of the market due to the fact that these certain goods and services should not be bought and sold in the first place. For example, markets in organs and blood, sex, and pregnancy surrogacy. In this paper, I intend on discussing two opposing views about market commodification. The first being Elizabeth Anderson, she argues that certain goods and services should not be for sale in a market, this is because the spread of these certain goods and services in markets would corrupt peoples personal and civic values. Also, Anderson is opposed to the commodification of these certain goods and services, like blood, sex, and pregnancy surrogacy, because it can easily exploit the people who sell them. In opposition to Anderson, Brennan and Jaworski argue in defense of commodification, but understand that not everything and anything should be allowed for sale on the market. Brennan and Jaworski argue that there are certain classes of goods and services that can be for sale and cannot be for sale. This is depending on whether or not the good or service is right to own or have in the first place. Both authors put out compelling arguments, and I will discuss each of their views on commodification. In closing IShow MoreRelateds Essays1002 Words   |  5 PagesCommoditification and its Affects The process of commodification is turning people into commodities (Rose, p. 302). Consequently, affecting our youth’s perception on societal perfection. Surely, it is also leaving medical professionals in nursing homes, and hospices empathetical blind to patients as people. According to Rose Wietz, author of A Critical Approach: The Sociology of Health, Illness, and Health Care, sociologist Timothy Diamond (1992) observed commodification and its impact on nursing home’s residentsRead MoreThe Social And Environmental Effects Associated With Commodifying Nature Essay1521 Words   |  7 Pageseffects associated with commodifying nature By Danielle Finestone The commodification of nature refers to transformation of natural resources to something generically valued for exchange within the market, this therefore leads to these common pool resources like freshwater being reconceptualised as a commercial resource. Natural goods and services become defined as tangible objects which can be privatized and managed under market rules (Gà ³mez-Baggethun Ruiz-Pà ©rez, 2011), as opposed to somethingRead MoreNotes On Price Mechanisms That We Have Today, Like The Spice And Silk Trade Routes1181 Words   |  5 Pagesprice mechanisms that we have today, like the spice and silk trade routes, but they were peripheral. These markets were usually only used for luxury goods or things that could not be gotten from within the community and society could operate without them (Flomenhof 99). So without principals of supply and demand to dictate price points of goods, economic stability and unity was sustained through the three principals: reciprocity, redis tribution, and householding. In his book he explains these principlesRead MoreThe Wealth Of Nations By Adam Smith1521 Words   |  7 Pagesbuying powers creates a market that is uninhibited by consumer ideals and morals. Lately, the reach of market values has started encompass aspects of life that it once did not. Michael Sandel wrote in his essay, Markets and Morals, â€Å"The more money can buy, the more affluence matters† (Morals and Markets 43 ¬).The â€Å"invisible hand† of the market has always gripped the throats of the poor and now with an expansion of market values the grip is becoming tighter. In the essay â€Å"Markets and Morals†, MichaelRead MoreNew Oriental Education And Technology Group1877 Words   |  8 PagesWhen considering the commodification of education, it is important to recognize that education has been progressively commoditized. Commodification is the transformation of goods and services, as well as ideas or other entities that normally may not be considered goods into a commodity. Today, education has to become a commodity for the benefit the unwashed masses. In developed countries, education often embedded in new technology is a key ingredient of commodification. Based on New Media an IntroductionRead MoreThe s Call For Individual s Responsibility Of Privacy Essay1806 Words   |  8 Pagesprivacy and selling user-data to advertisers (user commodification). Similarly, in her 2000 article, Free Labor: Producing Culture for the Digital Economy, Tiziana Terranova, through Marxist political economy, argues that the internet is a place for the exploitation of free labour (Terranova 33). Also, Terranova introduces the ideas of Richard Barbrook and his â€Å"digital economy,† where capitalism in the modern world relies on the commodification of user data and free labour exploitation (35-36).Read MoreThe Modern Economy Consists Of The Commodification Of Everything1629 Words   |  7 PagesThe modern economy consists of the commodification of everything. From education to tourist attractions, it’s no surprise that food and land has been manipulated to produce monetary outputs. What was once considered simply means of survival has evolved into an industry dominated by corporations that use unsustainable methods of production, therefore rapidly exhausting our natural resources. The shift from traditional farming with appropriate app reciation for the environment has long been discardedRead MoreThe Plantation As A Civilizing Factor By Ulrich Bonnell Phillips905 Words   |  4 Pagesâ€Å"Cuffy, Fancy Maids, and One-Eyed Men: Rape, Commodification, and the Domestic Slave Trade in the United States† by Edward E. Baptist was written in 2001. This article was published by an academic journal called the Oxford University Press. The author was an assistant professor at University of Miami. The author seems to b, rather obsessed with the idea of fetishes and rape. Even though the article is about fetishes, rape and commodification, it seems to convey the author obsession with thisRead MoreEssay on Unraveling the Issues of Compensated Organ Donations2023 Words   |  9 PagesIntroduction Compensated organ donations – one of the most controversial issues we have today. The scarcity of organ donations in America is the main reason there is a sudden diversion of possible source of organs. Beginning with donations of organs from cadaver to living donors, different strategies sprung just to reduce the said shortage; as a result of this quest, sale and paid organs is one of the approaches that gathered too much attention from the public. The controversy of paid organ donationsRead MoreSelecting the Gender of a Baby: The issue on whether parents should be allowed to choose the sex1500 Words   |  6 PagesSelecting the Gender of a Baby: The issue on whether parents should be allowed to choose the sex of their baby has been a major controversial issue in the recent past that has attracted huge debates between proponents and opponents of such practice. This issue has received huge attention because of long-term use of Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) to help pregnant women in the United States and across the globe. This technology basically involves the transfer of fertilized human embryos